With the Red Sox clinching the wild card last night, the races for the AL playoffs came to an end. The Red Sox will travel to Oakland Tuesday, and the Twins will head to the Bronx. With the BoSox up 12-0 after 4 against the Orioles, and the Cubs beating the Reds, I immediately started to mull over what I felt I would undoubtedly write about today: my AL playoff predictions. But then the Reds scored 6 times in the bottom of the 6th against the Zambrano-Veres-Guthrie combination. While I will make my AL playoff predictions, I feel that I can’t not address the Cubs’ collapse against the Reds last night.
Before the start of this season, Kerry Wood was my favorite Cub pitcher and had been since 1998. This year, Carlos Zambrano won my heart over because of his color: not only was he a dominant pitcher, but he was emotional. Whether it is a fist pump after a strikeout or a celebration after a base hit, Zambrano appears, at least, to play the game with wreckless abandon. And I love it. There are probably a lot of managers and coaches and “baseball men” that think that Zambrano’s antics are showy and unprofessional, but as a baseball fan, I love players like Zambrano.
Last night, Zambrano had his second consecutive poor outing. His line on the night:
5+ IP, 7 H, 5 ER, 5 BB, 5 K, 96 PT
On both Baseball Tonight and WGN’s broadcast of the Cubs game, they pointed to Zambrano’s frustration with himself as the melting point of his night. In the 6th inning, when Zambrano was having trouble hitting his spots, he started to get upset. Zambrano showed his frustration with the same passion as he shows his joy. He wasn’t just talking to himself as he paced around the mound; he was yelling and swearing at himself, absolutely livid that he could not hit his spots. Said Steve Stone: “Anger is a luxury a pitcher cannot afford.”
I don’t think it was his emotions getting the best of him that expelled Zambrano from the game. I think it was his sore back. After his last outing, Zambrano complained of pain in his lower back. After his disastrous outing in Pittsburgh, Zambrano had to return to Chicago for treatment. Naturally, after last night’s game, Zambrano would not place blame on his injury. Obviously, I don’t really know how Zambrano’s back feels, but I do have numbers:
The 8 starts before Pittsburgh and alleged back pain:
61 IP, 10 ER, 41 H, 21 BB, 50 K – ERA: 1.48, WHIP: 1.01
The 2 starts after alleged back pain:
9.2 IP, 11 ER, 15 H, 8 BB, 8 K – ERA: 10.24, WHIP: 2.38
I can hear my friend Ross hollering “small sample size!” about sample number two. True, it is a small sample size; but it doesn’t change the fact that Zambrano’s numbers skyrocketed in his last two starts, and that in his last two starts there have been reports in the Chicago Tribune of Zambrano feeling back and knee pain. An even more interesting statistic is the almighty Pitch Count, which came into play in a big way before Zambrano’s fateful outing against Pittsburgh. Zambrano threw a whopping 129 pitches in his final quality start of the season, losing a heartbreaker to the Reds, 1-0.
I am a believer in the A’s philosophy on pitch counts, which is very strict for young pitchers. Dusty Baker probably left Carlos Zambrano in the game too long that day against the Reds. Zambrano ended up losing that game 1-0, throwing a complete game and giving up just one run. I understand the situation of that game; it was close and Zambrano was throwing the ball very well. But I question Dusty Baker’s belief to keep Zambrano out there when the team is in a pennant race, and will need Zambrano later in the season, and potentially the postseason.
I will close with this: Carlos Zambrano has thrown more than 120 pitches five times all season. Here are his numbers in starts after he threw 120 or more pitches:
IP H ER BB SO ERA
6.2 5 4 4 5 5.40
6.0 8 3 3 7 4.50
6.0 7 4 4 2 6.00
7.0 5 2 3 3 2.57
4.2 8 6 3 3 11.57
6.0 6.6 3.8 3.4 4 5.67 120+ Average
6.2 5.9 2.3 2.9 5.3 3.11 Season Average
The numbers aren’t astronomically different (see Kerry Wood), but they are significant. Saving an extra 2.5 runs per nine innings is something that can really help the Cubs, a team that has had trouble scoring runs this season (they are 9th in the NL in runs scored).